Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad recipe

My family are self-proclaimed potato salad aficionados, and for years, the classic mayonnaise-laden version was the undisputed king of our summer barbecues. However, I’m always on the hunt for ways to elevate familiar dishes, to inject a little excitement into our weeknight meals and weekend gatherings. That’s when I stumbled upon the concept of smashed potato salad, and specifically, this Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad recipe. Let me tell you, it was a game-changer. The creamy, tangy buttermilk dressing, combined with the rustic texture of gently smashed potatoes, is a revelation. It’s lighter and brighter than traditional potato salad, yet still deeply satisfying and flavorful. From the first bite, my family was hooked. Even my youngest, who usually picks at potato salad, devoured a generous helping. The resounding verdict? This Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is not just good – it’s spectacular. It has become a staple in our house, perfect for potlucks, picnics, or simply as a delicious side dish to grilled chicken or fish. If you’re looking to break free from the ordinary and experience potato salad in a whole new, incredibly delicious way, then you absolutely must try this recipe. Get ready to fall in love with potato salad all over again!

Ingredients for Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad: The Building Blocks of Flavor

Creating the perfect Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is all about using high-quality ingredients that complement each other to create a symphony of flavors and textures. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what you’ll need, along with some helpful tips and variations:

For the Potatoes:

• 2 pounds Small Potatoes: The type of potato you choose is crucial for this recipe. We highly recommend using Yukon Gold potatoes. Their creamy texture and slightly waxy consistency are perfect for smashing without becoming mushy. They hold their shape beautifully after boiling and smashing, offering a delightful bite. Alternatively, you could use red potatoes, which also have a waxy texture and a slightly sweeter flavor. Avoid russet potatoes, as they are too starchy and tend to crumble when smashed. Using small potatoes is preferred because they cook faster and are naturally portioned for individual smashing. If you only have larger potatoes, simply cut them into roughly 2-inch pieces before boiling.
• Salt: Salt is essential for seasoning the potatoes both during boiling and in the final salad. Use kosher salt or sea salt for the best flavor. We will be using salt in multiple stages to ensure the potatoes are seasoned from the inside out.
• Water: For boiling the potatoes. Make sure you use enough water to fully submerge the potatoes to ensure even cooking.

For the Buttermilk Dressing:

• 1 cup Buttermilk: The star of the dressing! Buttermilk provides a wonderful tanginess and creamy texture that’s lighter and more refreshing than mayonnaise-based dressings. Real buttermilk is ideal for its authentic flavor and consistency. If you don’t have buttermilk on hand, you can make a quick substitute by adding 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar to 1 cup of milk. Let it sit for 5-10 minutes until it thickens slightly. While this works in a pinch, it won’t have the same depth of flavor as true buttermilk. For a richer dressing, consider using full-fat buttermilk.
• ½ cup Mayonnaise: A touch of mayonnaise adds richness and creaminess to the dressing, balancing the tanginess of the buttermilk. Use a good quality full-fat mayonnaise for the best flavor and texture. You can also use light mayonnaise for a slightly lighter version, but it might affect the overall richness. For a tangier flavor profile, consider using Duke’s mayonnaise, known for its vinegar-forward taste.
• ¼ cup Sour Cream: Sour cream further enhances the creaminess and tanginess of the dressing, adding another layer of complexity. Full-fat or low-fat sour cream will both work well. For a slightly richer flavor, opt for full-fat sour cream. If you prefer a tangier edge, you can substitute Greek yogurt for sour cream, but be aware it will result in a slightly thicker dressing.
• 2 tablespoons Dijon Mustard: Dijon mustard provides a sharp, savory kick that cuts through the richness of the dressing and complements the potatoes perfectly. Whole grain Dijon mustard can also be used for added texture and a slightly milder flavor. Avoid using yellow mustard, as its flavor profile is too different and won’t provide the desired complexity.
• 2 tablespoons Fresh Lemon Juice: Fresh lemon juice brightens the dressing and adds a vital touch of acidity, enhancing all the other flavors. Always use freshly squeezed lemon juice for the best taste. Bottled lemon juice can have a slightly metallic taste. Lime juice can be used as a substitute for a slightly different flavor profile.
• 1 tablespoon Chopped Fresh Dill: Fresh dill adds a bright, herbaceous, and slightly licorice-like note that is incredibly refreshing and pairs beautifully with potatoes and buttermilk. Fresh dill is highly recommended for its superior flavor. If you must use dried dill, use 1 teaspoon, but keep in mind the flavor will be less vibrant. Other fresh herbs like parsley, chives, or tarragon can be added or substituted to customize the flavor.
• 1 tablespoon Chopped Fresh Chives: Chives provide a mild oniony flavor that complements the dill and adds another layer of freshness. Fresh chives are best for their delicate flavor. If you don’t have fresh chives, you can substitute with finely chopped green onions or a pinch of onion powder in a pinch.
• 1 clove Garlic, minced: Garlic adds a savory depth and warmth to the dressing. Use freshly minced garlic for the best flavor. You can also use roasted garlic for a sweeter, milder garlic flavor. For a more subtle garlic flavor, you can rub the inside of the salad bowl with a cut garlic clove before adding the salad ingredients.
• ½ teaspoon Black Pepper: Freshly ground black pepper adds a touch of spice and enhances all the other flavors. Freshly ground black pepper is highly recommended for its superior aroma and flavor. White pepper can be used as a substitute for a milder pepper flavor.
• Salt (for dressing): Season the dressing to taste with salt. Start with a smaller amount and add more as needed, tasting as you go.

Optional Additions:

• Crispy Bacon: Crumbled crispy bacon adds a smoky, salty, and savory element that takes this potato salad to the next level. Cook bacon until crispy, drain excess fat, and crumble before adding to the salad.
• Pickled Red Onions: Thinly sliced pickled red onions add a tangy, sweet, and slightly crunchy element. They provide a beautiful color contrast and a burst of flavor.
• Hard-Boiled Eggs: Chopped hard-boiled eggs add richness and protein, making the salad more substantial.
• Celery: Finely diced celery adds a refreshing crunch and subtle celery flavor.

By using fresh, high-quality ingredients and paying attention to the balance of flavors, you’ll create a Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad that is truly unforgettable. Don’t be afraid to experiment with the optional additions to customize the recipe to your own taste preferences!

Instructions: Crafting the Perfect Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad

Making Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is a straightforward process, but following these detailed instructions will ensure you achieve potato salad perfection every time.

Step 1: Prepare and Boil the Potatoes

1. Wash the Potatoes: Thoroughly wash the small potatoes under cold running water to remove any dirt or debris. There’s no need to peel them, as the skins add texture and nutrients to the salad.
2. Place in a Pot and Cover with Water: Put the washed potatoes in a large pot. Cover them with cold water – enough water so that it’s about an inch above the potatoes. Starting with cold water ensures that the potatoes cook evenly from the inside out.
3. Salt the Water Generously: Add a generous amount of salt to the water. This is crucial for seasoning the potatoes from the inside as they cook. A good rule of thumb is about 1-2 tablespoons of salt per pot of water.
4. Bring to a Boil and Simmer: Bring the water to a rolling boil over high heat. Once boiling, reduce the heat to medium-low to maintain a gentle simmer.
5. Cook Until Tender: Simmer the potatoes until they are fork-tender. This usually takes about 15-20 minutes, depending on the size of your potatoes. To check for doneness, pierce a potato with a fork. It should easily slide in and out with minimal resistance. Avoid overcooking, as the potatoes will become mushy and difficult to smash.
6. Drain the Potatoes: Once the potatoes are cooked, carefully drain them in a colander. Let them sit in the colander for a few minutes to allow excess steam to escape. This will help them dry slightly and prevent the salad from becoming watery.

Step 2: Smash the Potatoes

1. Slightly Cool the Potatoes: Let the drained potatoes cool slightly for a few minutes until they are just cool enough to handle comfortably. You want them to still be warm, as they will smash more easily while warm.
2. Smash Gently: Place the slightly cooled potatoes in a large bowl. Using a potato masher, the bottom of a heavy glass or mug, or even a large fork, gently smash the potatoes. The goal is not to completely mash them, but to lightly smash them so they break open and become slightly flattened. You want to retain some chunks of potato for texture. Aim for a rustic, smashed look.
3. Don’t Over-Smash: Be careful not to over-smash the potatoes into a puree. You want a variety of textures – some smashed pieces and some larger chunks. Over-smashing will result in a mushy potato salad.

Step 3: Prepare the Buttermilk Dressing

1. Combine Dressing Ingredients: In a separate medium-sized bowl, whisk together the buttermilk, mayonnaise, sour cream, Dijon mustard, fresh lemon juice, chopped fresh dill, chopped fresh chives, minced garlic, black pepper, and salt.
2. Whisk Until Smooth: Whisk all the dressing ingredients together until they are well combined and smooth. Taste and adjust seasoning with more salt, pepper, or lemon juice as needed to your preference. The dressing should be tangy, creamy, and flavorful.

Step 4: Assemble the Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad

1. Pour Dressing Over Potatoes: Pour the prepared buttermilk dressing over the gently smashed potatoes in the large bowl.
2. Gently Toss to Combine: Gently toss the potatoes and dressing together until the potatoes are evenly coated with the dressing. Be careful not to overmix, as you want to maintain the smashed texture of the potatoes.
3. Optional Additions (if using): If you are using any optional additions like crispy bacon, pickled red onions, hard-boiled eggs, or celery, gently fold them into the potato salad at this stage.
4. Chill Before Serving: Cover the bowl with plastic wrap or a lid and refrigerate the potato salad for at least 30 minutes, or preferably 1-2 hours, to allow the flavors to meld and the salad to chill thoroughly. Chilling also helps the dressing thicken slightly.

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy!

1. Taste and Adjust Seasoning (Optional): Before serving, give the potato salad a final taste. Adjust seasoning with salt, pepper, or fresh herbs if needed.
2. Garnish (Optional): Garnish with extra fresh dill or chives, a sprinkle of paprika, or a drizzle of olive oil if desired, for visual appeal.
3. Serve Chilled: Serve the Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad chilled or at room temperature. It’s best enjoyed within 2-3 days of making.

Following these step-by-step instructions will guide you to create a delicious and flavorful Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad that will be a hit at any gathering. Enjoy the process and the incredible taste of this unique twist on classic potato salad!

Nutrition Facts: A Delicious and Reasonably Healthy Side Dish

Understanding the nutritional content of your meals is important, even when indulging in delicious side dishes like Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad. Here’s a general estimate of the nutrition facts for this recipe. Please note that these values are approximate and can vary based on specific ingredient brands, potato size, and portion sizes.

Servings: Approximately 8 servings

Serving Size: About ¾ cup to 1 cup

Approximate Nutrition Information per Serving:

• Calories: 250-300 calories
• Total Fat: 15-20g
  • Saturated Fat: 4-6g
  • Unsaturated Fat: 10-14g
• Cholesterol: 30-40mg
• Sodium: 400-500mg
• Total Carbohydrates: 25-30g
  • Dietary Fiber: 2-3g
  • Sugars: 2-3g
• Protein: 4-5g

Important Notes:

• These are estimates: Nutritional values can vary based on the specific ingredients used, brands, and portion sizes. For the most accurate information, use a nutrition calculator with the specific brands you are using.
• Healthy Fats: While this potato salad contains fat, much of it comes from mayonnaise and sour cream, which can include both saturated and unsaturated fats. When consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet, these fats are not inherently unhealthy.
• Sodium Content: The sodium content can be adjusted by using low-sodium mayonnaise or sour cream, and by carefully controlling the amount of salt added.
• Potassium Source: Potatoes are a good source of potassium, an important electrolyte.
• Customize for Health: You can make this potato salad lighter by using light mayonnaise and low-fat sour cream. You can also increase the fiber content by leaving the potato skins on and adding vegetables like celery or bell peppers.

Overall:

Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad, when enjoyed in moderation, can be a part of a balanced diet. It provides carbohydrates for energy, some protein, and healthy fats, along with vitamins and minerals from the potatoes and fresh herbs. Being mindful of portion sizes and ingredient choices allows you to enjoy this delicious side dish while staying within your dietary goals.

Preparation Time: Get Ready to Enjoy in Under an Hour

One of the great things about Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is that it’s relatively quick and easy to prepare, making it perfect for both planned gatherings and last-minute side dish needs. Here’s a breakdown of the preparation time:

Prep Time: 20 minutes

• Washing potatoes: 5 minutes
• Chopping fresh herbs and garlic: 10 minutes
• Measuring dressing ingredients: 5 minutes

Cook Time: 15-20 minutes

• Boiling potatoes: 15-20 minutes (depending on potato size)

Total Time: 35-40 minutes (excluding chilling time)

Chilling Time: Minimum 30 minutes, ideally 1-2 hours (recommended for best flavor and texture)

Total Time (Including Chilling): Approximately 1 hour to 1 hour and 30 minutes

Make-Ahead Friendly:

Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is an excellent make-ahead dish. You can prepare it completely several hours or even a day in advance. In fact, the flavors often meld and improve as it sits in the refrigerator. This makes it incredibly convenient for potlucks, parties, and busy weeknights.

Tips for Time Management:

• Multi-task: While the potatoes are boiling, you can prepare the buttermilk dressing and chop the herbs. This will save you time overall.
• Use Pre-Minced Garlic (with caution): If you are very short on time, you can use pre-minced garlic from a jar, but fresh garlic is always preferred for the best flavor.
• Chill Strategically: Plan your chilling time into your meal preparation schedule. If you need it quickly chilled, you can place the bowl in the freezer for 15-20 minutes (but be sure not to freeze it solid).

Quick and Delicious:

Despite its gourmet flavor profile, Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is surprisingly quick to make. In under an hour (including chilling), you can have a flavorful and impressive side dish ready to serve. Its efficient preparation time, combined with its make-ahead flexibility, makes it a winner for any occasion.

How to Serve Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad: Versatile Serving Suggestions

Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is incredibly versatile and pairs beautifully with a wide variety of dishes. Here are some delicious ways to serve it:

Classic BBQ and Picnic Pairings:

• Grilled Meats: Perfect alongside grilled chicken, steak, burgers, ribs, or sausages. The creamy, tangy potato salad cuts through the richness of grilled meats beautifully.
• BBQ Pulled Pork or Chicken Sandwiches: A fantastic side for BBQ sandwiches, adding a cool and refreshing element.
• Hot Dogs and Hamburgers: Elevate your classic cookout fare by serving this potato salad with hot dogs and hamburgers.
• Grilled Fish or Seafood: Pairs exceptionally well with grilled salmon, tuna steaks, shrimp skewers, or grilled white fish.
• Vegetarian BBQ Options: Serve with grilled veggie burgers, portobello mushroom burgers, or grilled halloumi.

Salads and Light Meals:

• Alongside Green Salads: A great addition to a lighter meal, served with a fresh green salad or a Caesar salad.
• With Sandwiches and Wraps: Perfect with deli sandwiches, wraps, or paninis for a satisfying lunch or light dinner.
• Protein Bowls: Add a scoop of Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad to protein bowls with grilled chicken, chickpeas, or tofu for a complete and balanced meal.
• Summer Luncheons: Ideal for summer luncheons and light gatherings, served alongside other salads and appetizers.

Potlucks and Parties:

• Potluck Favorite: Always a crowd-pleaser at potlucks, picnics, and parties. It’s easy to transport and serve.
• Buffet Style: Perfect for buffet-style meals, allowing guests to serve themselves.
• Holiday Gatherings: A welcome addition to holiday menus, especially for summer holidays like Memorial Day, Fourth of July, and Labor Day.

Serving Temperature and Garnishes:

• Serve Chilled or Room Temperature: Best served chilled or slightly cooled to room temperature. Avoid serving it warm, as the dressing may become too loose.
• Garnish Ideas:
  • Fresh Herbs: Sprinkle with extra chopped fresh dill, chives, or parsley for a fresh and vibrant look.
  • Paprika: A light dusting of paprika adds a touch of color and subtle smoky flavor.
  • Crumbled Bacon: If you added bacon to the salad, reserve some extra crispy bacon to sprinkle on top for garnish.
  • Pickled Red Onions: Add a few pickled red onion slices for a pop of color and tang.
  • Lemon Wedges: Serve with lemon wedges for guests to add an extra squeeze of fresh lemon juice if desired.
  • Olive Oil Drizzle: A drizzle of high-quality olive oil can add richness and sheen.

Presentation Tips:

• Attractive Bowl: Serve in a nice serving bowl that complements the salad.
• Garnish Creatively: Use garnishes to make the salad visually appealing.
• Label Clearly: If serving at a potluck or party, label the dish clearly, especially if it contains common allergens.

No matter how you choose to serve it, Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is sure to be a hit. Its creamy texture, tangy dressing, and rustic smashed potatoes make it a standout side dish for any occasion.

Additional Tips for Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad Perfection

Elevate your Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad from delicious to absolutely extraordinary with these five essential tips:

1. Don’t Overcook the Potatoes: The Key to Perfect Texture: The texture of smashed potato salad hinges on perfectly cooked potatoes. Overcooked potatoes will become mushy and fall apart when smashed, resulting in a gluey, undesirable consistency. Undercooked potatoes will be too firm and difficult to smash properly. Aim for “fork-tender” – the potatoes should be easily pierced with a fork but still hold their shape. Start checking for doneness around 15 minutes of simmering and test frequently until they reach the ideal tenderness. Remember, they will continue to soften slightly as they cool and absorb the dressing.
2. Smash Gently for Rustic Charm: The “smashed” aspect is what sets this potato salad apart. Resist the urge to fully mash the potatoes like you would for mashed potatoes. Instead, gently smash them to break them open and slightly flatten them, creating a rustic, chunky texture. Use a potato masher, the bottom of a heavy glass, or even a large fork, and apply gentle pressure. The goal is to create a mix of smashed pieces and some larger potato chunks for varied textures in each bite. Over-smashing will lead to a mushy salad, while under-smashing will miss the opportunity for the dressing to penetrate the potatoes effectively.
3. Make the Dressing Ahead for Flavor Fusion: The buttermilk dressing is the heart of this potato salad, and making it ahead of time allows the flavors to meld and deepen beautifully. Prepare the dressing at least an hour or two before you plan to assemble the salad, or even the day before. This resting period allows the herbs, garlic, and Dijon mustard to fully infuse into the buttermilk and mayonnaise, creating a more complex and flavorful dressing. Store the prepared dressing in an airtight container in the refrigerator until you’re ready to use it.
4. Chill Thoroughly for Optimal Taste and Texture: Chilling the Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is not just about temperature; it’s crucial for both flavor and texture. Refrigerating the salad for at least 30 minutes, and ideally 1-2 hours, allows the flavors to marry and deepen, creating a more harmonious and delicious dish. Chilling also helps the dressing to thicken slightly, coating the potatoes more effectively and improving the overall texture of the salad. If you’re short on time, even a quick 30-minute chill will make a noticeable difference.
5. Taste and Adjust Seasoning Before Serving: The Final Flourish: Before serving your Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad, always take a moment to taste and adjust the seasoning. Flavors can change slightly as the salad chills and the ingredients meld together. Taste a spoonful and decide if it needs a little more salt, a pinch of black pepper, a squeeze of fresh lemon juice for extra brightness, or perhaps a touch more fresh herbs for added aroma. This final adjustment ensures that your potato salad is perfectly balanced and bursting with flavor, making it truly memorable for everyone who enjoys it.

By following these five tips, you’ll be well on your way to creating Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad that is not only delicious but also perfectly textured and bursting with flavor. These small details make a big difference in elevating this recipe to its full potential.

FAQ: Your Questions About Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad Answered

Got questions about making the perfect Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad? We’ve compiled answers to some frequently asked questions to help you succeed every time:

Q1: Can I make Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad ahead of time?

A: Absolutely! In fact, making it ahead of time is highly recommended. Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is a fantastic make-ahead dish. You can prepare it completely 1-2 days in advance. The flavors actually improve as the salad sits in the refrigerator, allowing them to meld and deepen. Just store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator and give it a gentle stir before serving. This makes it perfect for potlucks, parties, or meal prepping.

Q2: Can I use a different type of potato?

A: While Yukon Gold potatoes are highly recommended for their creamy texture and waxy consistency, you can use other types of potatoes. Red potatoes are a good alternative as they also have a waxy texture and hold their shape well. Avoid using russet potatoes, as they are too starchy and tend to become dry and crumbly when smashed. If using larger potatoes, cut them into 2-inch pieces before boiling to ensure even cooking.

Q3: I don’t have buttermilk. Can I substitute something else?

A: Yes, you can make a buttermilk substitute. For every 1 cup of buttermilk needed, use 1 cup of milk (dairy or non-dairy) and add 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar. Stir and let it sit for 5-10 minutes until it thickens slightly and curdles. While this works as a substitute, real buttermilk will provide a richer and tangier flavor. You can also use plain yogurt or sour cream thinned with a little milk as a substitute, though the flavor profile will be slightly different.

Q4: Can I add other vegetables or ingredients to the potato salad?

A: Definitely! Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad is very versatile, and you can customize it with various additions to suit your taste. Some popular additions include:

• Crispy Bacon: Adds smoky, savory flavor and crunch.
• Pickled Red Onions: Provide tanginess, sweetness, and crunch.
• Hard-Boiled Eggs: Add richness and protein.
• Celery: Offers a refreshing crunch and subtle celery flavor.
• Bell Peppers (diced): Add color and a slightly sweet, crunchy element.
• Corn (grilled or roasted): Adds sweetness and summer flavor.
• Jalapeño (finely diced): For a touch of heat.

Feel free to experiment with your favorite vegetables and flavors to create your own signature version.

Q5: How long does Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad last in the refrigerator?

A: Properly stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator, Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad will last for 3-4 days. However, it’s best enjoyed within the first 2-3 days for optimal flavor and texture. Be sure to check for any signs of spoilage before consuming, such as an off odor or changes in texture. Dairy-based dressings can be sensitive to temperature changes, so it’s important to keep the potato salad consistently refrigerated to maintain its quality and safety.

We hope these FAQs have answered your questions and given you the confidence to make your own perfect batch of Smashed Buttermilk Potato Salad. Enjoy cooking and, more importantly, enjoy eating!

Print